4 Comments
User's avatar
Robert Tulip's avatar

The real danger is that acceleration itself is accelerating. That is the trend that best fits the data. Neglect of albedo loss is the primary scandal in climate politics.

Will Howard's avatar

The IPCC AR6 WGI "likely" estimate of Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity is also not that different from the 1970 Charney Report which concluded "We estimate the most probable warming for a doubling of CO₂ to be near 3℃ with a probable error of 1.5℃." In other words, 1.5 to 4.5℃. Compare to IPCC AR6: "likely in the range 2.5°C to 4.0°C, and very likely between 2.0°C and 5.0°C."

The problem is we're yet not in a position to rule out one end or the other of that range.

As you note ECS is defined as the warming from a doubling of CO2, once the climate system reaches steady-state. In other words, the energy imbalance reaches zero. How long it takes for that steady state to be restored remains uncertain. But most likely the time scales are on the order of centuries because of the role of the oceans in the earth's energy budget. The significance of the recent CERES up-tick for ECS will take some time to work out and I'd say also uncertain. Of course I could be wrong ...

Miguelitro's avatar

IPCC reports at the granular scale have consistently emphasized the deep uncertainty in measuring climate sensitivity. The truth is we’ve never been able to model the atmosphere at a small enough scale to address clouds and aerosols. The misleading starts with the IPCC executive summaries and then really into reckless false precision land in the media. Now we are paying the price for environmentalist irresponsibility. I used to be one at NRDC where I was a Senior Attorney.

To my knowledge, there is no massive qualitative improvement in modeling capacity on the horizon so humanity will continue to operate pretty much in the dark on what the future holds.

And people are experiencing deep credibility fatigue as a result. Policy responses at a sufficiently large scale are now less likely than ever. Ironically just as we are receiving evidence that the problem could be far worse.

The boy who cried wolf writ large. We’re just going to have to hang on tight as we steer the ship blindfolded.

Archival Aardvark's avatar

This is a nice introduction and I share your concern but I do think this overstates the consensus even on the acceleration and EEI, and what it all means.

I’m not sure many earth scientists would agree that all of the evidence is gathering on the high sensitivity side.

There is still a lot of debate on what the cloud feedback means, for example: https://www.pnnl.gov/publications/recent-cloud-trends-and-extremes-reaffirm-established-bounds-cloud-feedback-and